Skip to main content
Live Action LogoLive Action
premature, born alive, Rhode Island, abortion

Abortionist fails to pay malpractice for baby born alive during abortion

Live Action News - Investigative IconInvestigative·By Anna Reynolds

Abortionist fails to pay malpractice for baby born alive during abortion

While the abortion industry continues to claim that abortion survivors “don’t exist,” one abortionist’s ongoing legal dispute with the family of a girl born alive in an abortion at his facility is proof that babies do sometimes survive the “procedures” meant to kill them. Operation Rescue reports that Florida abortionist James Scott Pendergraft IV allegedly hid financial assets in order to avoid paying the family of a girl born alive in a botched abortion. Of the almost $37 million malpractice judgment against Pendergraft, Operation Rescue reports he is personally responsible to pay almost $12 million.

The case involves a woman identified in court documents as C.H. who went to Pendergraft’s Orlando Women’s Center on November 15, 2001. Then 20 years old, C.H. was seeking an elective abortion at what she thought was around 18-20 weeks. She was actually more than 22 weeks pregnant. Unlicensed clinic staff administered the abortion pill RU-486 — which is not approved by for use after the tenth week of pregnancy — and other drugs, despite the fact that she was more than 22 weeks pregnant.

C.H. was in severe pain and having contractions. Allegedly, abortion workers told C.H. to “walk off her labor in the parking lot, and if she didn’t like that, she could leave.” C.H. did leave and later went to the local hospital where her daughter J.F. was born via caesarean section.

READ: 16 infants in Florida born alive after surviving abortion attempts

Today, J.F. is 17 years old and reportedly continues to suffer effects of the botched abortion — a seizure disorder and physical and mental developmental delays. Although Pendergraft was serving a prison sentence for extortion at the time of J.F.’s birth, jurors decided that he was responsible for the horrific injuries suffered by C.H. and her daughter because his staff was following the illegal and dangerous protocols he had established.

There is evidence that C.H.’s case was not an outlier, and there may have been countless other babies born alive at Pendergraft’s abortion facility. In fact, the website for the Orlando Women’s Center states, “If the labor induction method is used, there is a small chance that the baby could live for a short period of time.”

Article continues below

Dear Reader,

In 2026, Live Action is heading straight where the battle is fiercest: college campuses.

We have a bold initiative to establish 100 Live Action campus chapters within the next year, and your partnership will make it a success!

Your support today will help train and equip young leaders, bring Live Action’s educational content into academic environments, host on-campus events and debates, and empower students to challenge the pro-abortion status quo with truth and compassion.

Invest in pro-life grassroots outreach and cultural formation with your DOUBLED year-end gift!

Thumbnail for 3rd Trimester Induction Abortion: Injection and Stillbirth

 

Operation Rescue outlines how Pendergraft has failed to pay J.F. and her family for the cost of her medical treatment and setting up a medical trust to ensure her future care. Pendergraft appears to still be involved in multiple abortion businesses and a marijuana dispensary.

Pendergraft, in addition to his apparent ongoing involvement with these businesses, was arrested during a traffic stop in South Carolina. He was found to be selling illicit drugs and committing abortions from his van. The van contained bloody surgical instruments with human tissue on them. This illegal activity generated a cash income that could not be rightfully seized and given to J.F. and her family.

Operation Rescue also reports that C.H.’s lawyers allege that Pendergraft transferred money to his attorneys as part of a money-laundering scheme.

“Like” Live Action News on Facebook for more pro-life news and commentary!

Live Action News is pro-life news and commentary from a pro-life perspective.

Contact editor@liveaction.org for questions, corrections, or if you are seeking permission to reprint any Live Action News content.

Guest Articles: To submit a guest article to Live Action News, email editor@liveaction.org with an attached Word document of 800-1000 words. Please also attach any photos relevant to your submission if applicable. If your submission is accepted for publication, you will be notified within three weeks. Guest articles are not compensated (see our Open License Agreement). Thank you for your interest in Live Action News!

Read Next

Read NextBIRMINGHAM, ENGLAND - JULY 30: Jack Osbourne, Sharon Osbourne, Kelly Osbourne and family members stop to view tributes to the late Ozzy Osbourne from fans at Black Sabbath Bench and Bridge as his funeral cortege travels through his home city of Birmingham on July 30, 2025 in Birmingham, England. The Black Sabbath frontman passed away on July 22nd at the age of 76. His death occurred just a little over two weeks after his final live performance at the 'Back to the Beginning' concert in his hometown of Birmingham.
Pop Culture

Sharon Osbourne says her kids and grandkids are 'the reason' she's still alive

Cassy Cooke

·

Spotlight Articles