
Should we revisit fertility awareness in light of shocking contraceptive study?
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Texas Supreme Court dismisses Planned Parenthood lawsuit over Heartbeat Act
The Supreme Court of Texas has unanimously dismissed a Planned Parenthood lawsuit against Texas Right to Life over the state's pro-life Heartbeat Act.
The Texas Supreme Court has dismissed a legal challenge by Planned Parenthood against Texas Right to Life over the Heartbeat Act.
The case was dismissed for "want of jurisdiction." The court said Planned Parenthood's claim was "moot."
The 2021 Heartbeat Act allows any person to file a civil lawsuit against someone who commits or assists in an abortion.
In 2022, Texas enacted the Human Life Protection Act, which may have been the justices' reasoning for dismissing the case.
Texas defines abortion as:
[T]he act of using or prescribing an instrument, a drug, a medicine, or any other substance, device, or means with the intent to cause the death of an unborn child of a woman known to be pregnant. The term does not include birth control devices or oral contraceptives. An act is not an abortion if the act is done with the intent to:
(A) save the life or preserve the health of an unborn child;
(B) remove a dead, unborn child whose death was caused by spontaneous abortion; or
(C) remove an ectopic pregnancy.
The Texas Heartbeat Act took effect in 2021, allowing any person to file a civil lawsuit against anyone who commits or assists in an abortion. The day after the Heartbeat Act took effect, Planned Parenthood affiliates filed a lawsuit against Texas Right to Life, its Legislative Director, John Seago, and 100 people who were not named. The lawsuit was aimed at stopping pro-lifers from suing Planned Parenthood and the affiliates under the law.
"When the Texas Heartbeat Act first took effect in 2021, Planned Parenthood couldn’t sue the state like they normally do. That’s why they set their sights on Texas Right to Life and our president, Dr. John Seago, who was personally named in this lawsuit," said Texas Right to Life in a press release. "The pro-abortion attorneys stated in court, 'Texas Right to Life and John Seago are the biggest threats to Planned Parenthood.' The Texas Heartbeat Act is unique – it’s not enforced by the state – so it doesn’t matter if Texas officials are Republican or Democrat. Instead, the law lets regular citizens sue abortionists if they illegally kill preborn babies."
In all, 14 lawsuits were filed against Texas Right to Life "because, according to plaintiffs’ petitions, they had previously announced their intention to bring lawsuits under the Act." The 14 cases were consolidated. Texas Right to Life moved to dismiss the plaintiffs’ claims under the Texas Citizens Participation Act, arguing that they lacked standing. That was denied, and Texas Right to Life appealed.
As that appeal proceeded, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down its decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, allowing states to protect preborn babies from abortion prior to viability. That ruling allowed Texas' Human Life Protection Act to go into effect, protecting most babies from abortion from the moment of fertilization.
As the Texas Supreme Court ruling states:
The significance of Dobbs for this case is that it triggered the effective date of a separate Texas statute regulating abortion. See Human Life Protection Act of 2021... (stating that the Act takes effect “on the 30th day after . . . the issuance of a United States Supreme Court judgment in a decision overruling, wholly or partly, Roe v. Wade”). That statute, with certain exceptions, prohibits persons from “knowingly perform[ing], induc[ing], or attempt[ing] an abortion,” ... and it imposes both criminal punishment and civil penalties enforceable by the Attorney General for a violation...
According to the Texas Supreme Court's ruling:
In this interlocutory appeal from the denial of a motion to dismiss, the plaintiffs concede that their affirmative claims are now moot and the case should be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. The defendants respond that the plaintiffs’ claims cannot be moot because they never had standing to begin with. We hold that, either way, there is no justiciable controversy before us, so we dismiss the case.
It further explained:
[P]laintiffs filed a motion to dismiss the case as moot. They argue that their claims are moot because TRTL and Seago are now barred by limitations from suing them. According to plaintiffs—and consistent with the position TRTL and Seago previously embraced—no Texas physician has performed a prohibited abortion since the Human Life Protection Act took effect in August 2022. Because a civil action under the Heartbeat Act must be brought within four years of the violation... plaintiffs now concede that they do not face any threat of a civil lawsuit under that Act, meaning they have no concrete injury that would be remedied by the relief they request in their suit...
After five years of court battles, the state Supreme Court dismissed the case against Texas Right to Life for "want of jurisdiction." The justices did not state whether Planned Parenthood and the other plaintiffs lacked standing from the start of the case or whether the claims became moot after the Human Life Protection Act was enacted. "[E]ither way," the justices ruled, "there is no justiciable controversy before us."
Texas Right to Life responded to the ruling, saying, "Abortion activists’ ridiculously long legal attack not only targeted preborn children, but also harassed Texas Right to Life for our exercise of free speech. Friday’s ruling dismissed the case for lack of jurisdiction, reversed a lower court’s opinion that the Pro-Life law was likely unconstitutional, and kept the Texas Heartbeat Act in full force. Private citizens may still sue abortionists and others who illegally kill babies."
But it also noted, "Now, going forward into 2027, when we can’t depend on the state government to save babies from abortion, Texas Right to Life is praising God for this victory—ensuring Texans can still hold illegal abortionists accountable for their crimes when our elected officials refuse to act. Private lawsuits are the Pro-Life movement’s most effective and promising tool against abortionists and activists who murder babies and harm women."
Live Action News is pro-life news and commentary from a pro-life perspective.
Our work is possible because of our donors. Please consider giving to further our work of changing hearts and minds on issues of life and human dignity.
Contact editor@liveaction.org for questions, corrections, or if you are seeking permission to reprint any Live Action News content.
Guest Articles: To submit a guest article to Live Action News, email editor@liveaction.org with an attached Word document of 800-1000 words. Please also attach any photos relevant to your submission if applicable. If your submission is accepted for publication, you will be notified within three weeks. Guest articles are not compensated (see our Open License Agreement). Thank you for your interest in Live Action News!

Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Politics
Cassy Cooke
·
International
Bridget Sielicki
·
Politics
Cassy Cooke
·
Politics
Bridget Sielicki
·
Politics
Cassy Cooke
·
Investigative
Nancy Flanders
·
Abortion Pill
Nancy Flanders
·
Abortion Pill
Nancy Flanders
·
Analysis
Nancy Flanders
·
Investigative
Nancy Flanders
·
Texas Supreme Court dismisses Planned Parenthood lawsuit over Heartbeat Act
The Supreme Court of Texas has unanimously dismissed a Planned Parenthood lawsuit against Texas Right to Life over the state's pro-life Heartbeat Act.
The Texas Supreme Court has dismissed a legal challenge by Planned Parenthood against Texas Right to Life over the Heartbeat Act.
The case was dismissed for "want of jurisdiction." The court said Planned Parenthood's claim was "moot."
The 2021 Heartbeat Act allows any person to file a civil lawsuit against someone who commits or assists in an abortion.
In 2022, Texas enacted the Human Life Protection Act, which may have been the justices' reasoning for dismissing the case.
Texas defines abortion as:
[T]he act of using or prescribing an instrument, a drug, a medicine, or any other substance, device, or means with the intent to cause the death of an unborn child of a woman known to be pregnant. The term does not include birth control devices or oral contraceptives. An act is not an abortion if the act is done with the intent to:
(A) save the life or preserve the health of an unborn child;
(B) remove a dead, unborn child whose death was caused by spontaneous abortion; or
(C) remove an ectopic pregnancy.
The Texas Heartbeat Act took effect in 2021, allowing any person to file a civil lawsuit against anyone who commits or assists in an abortion. The day after the Heartbeat Act took effect, Planned Parenthood affiliates filed a lawsuit against Texas Right to Life, its Legislative Director, John Seago, and 100 people who were not named. The lawsuit was aimed at stopping pro-lifers from suing Planned Parenthood and the affiliates under the law.
"When the Texas Heartbeat Act first took effect in 2021, Planned Parenthood couldn’t sue the state like they normally do. That’s why they set their sights on Texas Right to Life and our president, Dr. John Seago, who was personally named in this lawsuit," said Texas Right to Life in a press release. "The pro-abortion attorneys stated in court, 'Texas Right to Life and John Seago are the biggest threats to Planned Parenthood.' The Texas Heartbeat Act is unique – it’s not enforced by the state – so it doesn’t matter if Texas officials are Republican or Democrat. Instead, the law lets regular citizens sue abortionists if they illegally kill preborn babies."
In all, 14 lawsuits were filed against Texas Right to Life "because, according to plaintiffs’ petitions, they had previously announced their intention to bring lawsuits under the Act." The 14 cases were consolidated. Texas Right to Life moved to dismiss the plaintiffs’ claims under the Texas Citizens Participation Act, arguing that they lacked standing. That was denied, and Texas Right to Life appealed.
As that appeal proceeded, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down its decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, allowing states to protect preborn babies from abortion prior to viability. That ruling allowed Texas' Human Life Protection Act to go into effect, protecting most babies from abortion from the moment of fertilization.
As the Texas Supreme Court ruling states:
The significance of Dobbs for this case is that it triggered the effective date of a separate Texas statute regulating abortion. See Human Life Protection Act of 2021... (stating that the Act takes effect “on the 30th day after . . . the issuance of a United States Supreme Court judgment in a decision overruling, wholly or partly, Roe v. Wade”). That statute, with certain exceptions, prohibits persons from “knowingly perform[ing], induc[ing], or attempt[ing] an abortion,” ... and it imposes both criminal punishment and civil penalties enforceable by the Attorney General for a violation...
According to the Texas Supreme Court's ruling:
In this interlocutory appeal from the denial of a motion to dismiss, the plaintiffs concede that their affirmative claims are now moot and the case should be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. The defendants respond that the plaintiffs’ claims cannot be moot because they never had standing to begin with. We hold that, either way, there is no justiciable controversy before us, so we dismiss the case.
It further explained:
[P]laintiffs filed a motion to dismiss the case as moot. They argue that their claims are moot because TRTL and Seago are now barred by limitations from suing them. According to plaintiffs—and consistent with the position TRTL and Seago previously embraced—no Texas physician has performed a prohibited abortion since the Human Life Protection Act took effect in August 2022. Because a civil action under the Heartbeat Act must be brought within four years of the violation... plaintiffs now concede that they do not face any threat of a civil lawsuit under that Act, meaning they have no concrete injury that would be remedied by the relief they request in their suit...
After five years of court battles, the state Supreme Court dismissed the case against Texas Right to Life for "want of jurisdiction." The justices did not state whether Planned Parenthood and the other plaintiffs lacked standing from the start of the case or whether the claims became moot after the Human Life Protection Act was enacted. "[E]ither way," the justices ruled, "there is no justiciable controversy before us."
Texas Right to Life responded to the ruling, saying, "Abortion activists’ ridiculously long legal attack not only targeted preborn children, but also harassed Texas Right to Life for our exercise of free speech. Friday’s ruling dismissed the case for lack of jurisdiction, reversed a lower court’s opinion that the Pro-Life law was likely unconstitutional, and kept the Texas Heartbeat Act in full force. Private citizens may still sue abortionists and others who illegally kill babies."
But it also noted, "Now, going forward into 2027, when we can’t depend on the state government to save babies from abortion, Texas Right to Life is praising God for this victory—ensuring Texans can still hold illegal abortionists accountable for their crimes when our elected officials refuse to act. Private lawsuits are the Pro-Life movement’s most effective and promising tool against abortionists and activists who murder babies and harm women."
Live Action News is pro-life news and commentary from a pro-life perspective.
Our work is possible because of our donors. Please consider giving to further our work of changing hearts and minds on issues of life and human dignity.
Contact editor@liveaction.org for questions, corrections, or if you are seeking permission to reprint any Live Action News content.
Guest Articles: To submit a guest article to Live Action News, email editor@liveaction.org with an attached Word document of 800-1000 words. Please also attach any photos relevant to your submission if applicable. If your submission is accepted for publication, you will be notified within three weeks. Guest articles are not compensated (see our Open License Agreement). Thank you for your interest in Live Action News!

Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Politics
Cassy Cooke
·
International
Bridget Sielicki
·
Politics
Cassy Cooke
·
Politics
Bridget Sielicki
·
Politics
Cassy Cooke
·
Investigative
Nancy Flanders
·
Abortion Pill
Nancy Flanders
·
Abortion Pill
Nancy Flanders
·
Analysis
Nancy Flanders
·
Investigative
Nancy Flanders
·