
Ohio abortion-related laws likely to face legal challenges if signed by governor
Bridget Sielicki
·
Issues·By Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
Should we revisit fertility awareness in light of shocking contraceptive study?
Though we've heard for years that long-acting contraceptives implanted or inserted by healthcare professionals are more effective for pregnancy prevention than short-acting, user-dependent ones, a recent study found that this might just be a myth — and it might have something to say about fertility awareness methods, too.
A recent study found that with appropriate support and removal of barriers to access, pregnancy prevention effectiveness was close to equal across various contraceptive methods.
This surprised researchers, as the failure rate across all methods was just 2.2%. Failure rates were not markedly different across contraceptive methods. Even the condom failure rate (2.6%) was far lower than previous research found.
While users of fertility awareness (natural family planning) were deliberately excluded from participation, the study results point to the idea that, when given proper support and education, women can effectively use chosen methods of pregnancy prevention that were once thought to be less effective than others.
Fertility awareness methods are the only family planning method that don’t entail significant potential health risks for the user, and can be used to try to conceive when a woman’s pregnancy intention changes.
Fertility awareness users should enjoy the same ease of access, use, and support as this study's participants.
Researchers at the University of Utah partnered with four Salt Lake City-area Planned Parenthood recruits for HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative (HER stands for Highly Effective Reversible), a study on what happens when you remove common barriers to contraceptive access and allow women to change their method relatively easily.
Researchers asked the question, “With person-centered contraceptive counseling and same-day method access, what are 3-year continuation and typical-use failure rates for reversible contraceptive methods?”
In other words, when barriers are removed, what do women choose, what do they stick with, and how effective are their chosen methods?
From September 2015 to March 2017, researchers conducted a prospective longitudinal cohort study on 4,275 women aged 18-45 who lived below the poverty line. The goal was to follow these women for three years, and they were largely successful. Ninety percent (90%) were still participating at one year, 84% at two years, and 82% made it the full three years.
At the beginning of the study (graphic here):
13% of participants were using condoms, diaphragms, or emergency contraception;
21% were getting the progestin-only Depo Provera birth control shot;
40% were using the pill, the patch, or the vaginal ring;
20% were using IUDs or contraceptive implants.
The study intervention was to allow women free access to any of the above methods of their choice, on the same day as their initial appointment, with free refills or supplies for up to three months at a time.
“Person-centered counseling” was utilized, though I could not find specifics on what that counseling approach entailed other than that the “10 best practices contraceptive counseling protocol” was implemented.
Over the following three years, these women were supported in their method of choice and there were no penalties for switching to another method if they desired to do so.
(Of note: the study does not specify whether women were supported in having their IUD or implant removed if they so chose. Anecdotal evidence suggests that patients sometimes receive pushback from their practitioners and had to pay large fees to have their LARC removed).
Given choices and free access, the majority of women were using long-acting reversible contraception (LARC), meaning IUDs or implants, by the end of the study.
This is unsurprising, since these methods would typically be financially out of reach for impoverished women, but were available for free during the study. The study was intentionally designed not to push women towards LARC, but instead to grant them free access and options. This was out of respect for patient autonomy and with acknowledgment that impoverished women and racial minorities have historically had their contraceptive choices dictated to them or, even worse, undergone forced contraception or sterilization against their will or without their consent.
Many women changed methods over the course of the study.
A majority of copper IUD or implant users stuck with their method for all three years.
35% of pill users, 34% of vaginal ring users, 33% of Depo Provera shot users, and 15% of male condom users continued their method.
By the end of the study:
Use of condoms, diaphragms, and emergency contraception went down from 14% to 8%
Use of the progestin-only birth control shot Depo-Provera decreased from 21% to 13%
Use of the contraceptive pill, patch, and ring remained essentially unchanged at 39-40%
Use of long-acting reversible contraceptives like implanted contraceptives and IUDs increased from 20% to 34%.
The results of the study surprised everyone.
As the researchers noted:
While LARCs demonstrated high contraceptive effectiveness in our research, we found that all methods, when chosen according to patient preference and supported with same-day access and multiple months of the method, showed higher contraceptive effectiveness rates than previously reported.
That’s right. Out of 4,275 participants, 41% of whom were aged 20-24, 96 unintended pregnancies occurred, for an unintended pregnancy rate of 2.2% across all methods.
Failure rates were not markedly different across contraceptive methods, and even the failure rate with male condoms (2.6%) was far lower than previous research has found.
This is fascinating for two reasons:
First, failure rates in clinician-dependent contraceptives, including the arm implant, the IUD, and the copper IUD, were higher than in previously published research studies (though this is in keeping with some research finding that LARCs aren’t as bomb-proof as advertised).
Second, failure rates in user-dependent contraceptives, including the pill, patch, ring, and male condoms, were markedly lower than typical-use rates in previously published research studies.
Hormonal IUD users had 0.7 pregnancies/100 participants, implant users had 0.8 pregnancies, copper IUD users had 1.1 pregnancies, Depo Provera users had 1.1 pregnancies, vaginal ring users had 1.4, pill users had 1.6 pregnancies, and male condom users (the least effective method) had 2.6 pregnancies.
While the landmark 2012 Contraceptive CHOICE study found a 20-fold difference in pregnancy prevention effectiveness between the most-effective and least-effective contraceptive options, the HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative found just a two-fold difference between the top and lowest performing methods.
Researchers suspect that “removing access barriers to preferred contraceptive methods may support access to clinician-dependent LARC methods, like IUDs and implants, and improve the contraceptive effectiveness of user-controlled, shorter-acting methods.”
Translation: when you give women the support and education they need, they are able to achieve their family planning goals successfully, even with methods presumed less effective.
Who else might this principle apply to?
Fertility awareness users were explicitly prohibited from inclusion in the study, along with those who used withdrawal or no method at all.
Over and over, we’re told by the internet in general and some medical professionals in particular that fertility awareness methods could “never work” in the real world for the average woman who has a busy life, or an irregular cycle, or both.
And yet fertility awareness methods are the only family planning method that doesn’t entail significant potential health risks for the user, and can be used to try to conceive when a woman’s pregnancy intention changes.
In the hands of professionals who know how to read them, cycle charts can even help identify reproductive health issues, and the menstrual cycle is considered a ‘fifth vital sign’ of overall health in women.
What if fertility awareness users enjoyed the same ease of access, use, and support as HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative participants?
And while, as some have rightly pointed out, a woman working three jobs to make ends meet may not be able to attend a three-and-a-half-hour introductory class or multiple hour-long follow-ups to learn a fertility awareness method, there are organizations working to distill the essential components of mainline, evidence-based fertility awareness methods for use by those least equipped to deal with nasty side effects or health fallout from hormonal-based methods.
The HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative showed what can happen when women are able to access contraceptive methods in a timely fashion and for free. When will fertility awareness methods enjoy the same level of support?
Live Action News is pro-life news and commentary from a pro-life perspective.
Our work is possible because of our donors. Please consider giving to further our work of changing hearts and minds on issues of life and human dignity.
Contact editor@liveaction.org for questions, corrections, or if you are seeking permission to reprint any Live Action News content.
Guest Articles: To submit a guest article to Live Action News, email editor@liveaction.org with an attached Word document of 800-1000 words. Please also attach any photos relevant to your submission if applicable. If your submission is accepted for publication, you will be notified within three weeks. Guest articles are not compensated (see our Open License Agreement). Thank you for your interest in Live Action News!

Bridget Sielicki
·
Issues
Bernadette Pate
·
Issues
Bridget Sielicki
·
Issues
Sheena Rodriguez
·
Issues
Cassy Cooke
·
International
Cassy Cooke
·
Analysis
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Human Interest
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Issues
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Issues
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Issues
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Issues·By Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
Should we revisit fertility awareness in light of shocking contraceptive study?
Though we've heard for years that long-acting contraceptives implanted or inserted by healthcare professionals are more effective for pregnancy prevention than short-acting, user-dependent ones, a recent study found that this might just be a myth — and it might have something to say about fertility awareness methods, too.
A recent study found that with appropriate support and removal of barriers to access, pregnancy prevention effectiveness was close to equal across various contraceptive methods.
This surprised researchers, as the failure rate across all methods was just 2.2%. Failure rates were not markedly different across contraceptive methods. Even the condom failure rate (2.6%) was far lower than previous research found.
While users of fertility awareness (natural family planning) were deliberately excluded from participation, the study results point to the idea that, when given proper support and education, women can effectively use chosen methods of pregnancy prevention that were once thought to be less effective than others.
Fertility awareness methods are the only family planning method that don’t entail significant potential health risks for the user, and can be used to try to conceive when a woman’s pregnancy intention changes.
Fertility awareness users should enjoy the same ease of access, use, and support as this study's participants.
Researchers at the University of Utah partnered with four Salt Lake City-area Planned Parenthood recruits for HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative (HER stands for Highly Effective Reversible), a study on what happens when you remove common barriers to contraceptive access and allow women to change their method relatively easily.
Researchers asked the question, “With person-centered contraceptive counseling and same-day method access, what are 3-year continuation and typical-use failure rates for reversible contraceptive methods?”
In other words, when barriers are removed, what do women choose, what do they stick with, and how effective are their chosen methods?
From September 2015 to March 2017, researchers conducted a prospective longitudinal cohort study on 4,275 women aged 18-45 who lived below the poverty line. The goal was to follow these women for three years, and they were largely successful. Ninety percent (90%) were still participating at one year, 84% at two years, and 82% made it the full three years.
At the beginning of the study (graphic here):
13% of participants were using condoms, diaphragms, or emergency contraception;
21% were getting the progestin-only Depo Provera birth control shot;
40% were using the pill, the patch, or the vaginal ring;
20% were using IUDs or contraceptive implants.
The study intervention was to allow women free access to any of the above methods of their choice, on the same day as their initial appointment, with free refills or supplies for up to three months at a time.
“Person-centered counseling” was utilized, though I could not find specifics on what that counseling approach entailed other than that the “10 best practices contraceptive counseling protocol” was implemented.
Over the following three years, these women were supported in their method of choice and there were no penalties for switching to another method if they desired to do so.
(Of note: the study does not specify whether women were supported in having their IUD or implant removed if they so chose. Anecdotal evidence suggests that patients sometimes receive pushback from their practitioners and had to pay large fees to have their LARC removed).
Given choices and free access, the majority of women were using long-acting reversible contraception (LARC), meaning IUDs or implants, by the end of the study.
This is unsurprising, since these methods would typically be financially out of reach for impoverished women, but were available for free during the study. The study was intentionally designed not to push women towards LARC, but instead to grant them free access and options. This was out of respect for patient autonomy and with acknowledgment that impoverished women and racial minorities have historically had their contraceptive choices dictated to them or, even worse, undergone forced contraception or sterilization against their will or without their consent.
Many women changed methods over the course of the study.
A majority of copper IUD or implant users stuck with their method for all three years.
35% of pill users, 34% of vaginal ring users, 33% of Depo Provera shot users, and 15% of male condom users continued their method.
By the end of the study:
Use of condoms, diaphragms, and emergency contraception went down from 14% to 8%
Use of the progestin-only birth control shot Depo-Provera decreased from 21% to 13%
Use of the contraceptive pill, patch, and ring remained essentially unchanged at 39-40%
Use of long-acting reversible contraceptives like implanted contraceptives and IUDs increased from 20% to 34%.
The results of the study surprised everyone.
As the researchers noted:
While LARCs demonstrated high contraceptive effectiveness in our research, we found that all methods, when chosen according to patient preference and supported with same-day access and multiple months of the method, showed higher contraceptive effectiveness rates than previously reported.
That’s right. Out of 4,275 participants, 41% of whom were aged 20-24, 96 unintended pregnancies occurred, for an unintended pregnancy rate of 2.2% across all methods.
Failure rates were not markedly different across contraceptive methods, and even the failure rate with male condoms (2.6%) was far lower than previous research has found.
This is fascinating for two reasons:
First, failure rates in clinician-dependent contraceptives, including the arm implant, the IUD, and the copper IUD, were higher than in previously published research studies (though this is in keeping with some research finding that LARCs aren’t as bomb-proof as advertised).
Second, failure rates in user-dependent contraceptives, including the pill, patch, ring, and male condoms, were markedly lower than typical-use rates in previously published research studies.
Hormonal IUD users had 0.7 pregnancies/100 participants, implant users had 0.8 pregnancies, copper IUD users had 1.1 pregnancies, Depo Provera users had 1.1 pregnancies, vaginal ring users had 1.4, pill users had 1.6 pregnancies, and male condom users (the least effective method) had 2.6 pregnancies.
While the landmark 2012 Contraceptive CHOICE study found a 20-fold difference in pregnancy prevention effectiveness between the most-effective and least-effective contraceptive options, the HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative found just a two-fold difference between the top and lowest performing methods.
Researchers suspect that “removing access barriers to preferred contraceptive methods may support access to clinician-dependent LARC methods, like IUDs and implants, and improve the contraceptive effectiveness of user-controlled, shorter-acting methods.”
Translation: when you give women the support and education they need, they are able to achieve their family planning goals successfully, even with methods presumed less effective.
Who else might this principle apply to?
Fertility awareness users were explicitly prohibited from inclusion in the study, along with those who used withdrawal or no method at all.
Over and over, we’re told by the internet in general and some medical professionals in particular that fertility awareness methods could “never work” in the real world for the average woman who has a busy life, or an irregular cycle, or both.
And yet fertility awareness methods are the only family planning method that doesn’t entail significant potential health risks for the user, and can be used to try to conceive when a woman’s pregnancy intention changes.
In the hands of professionals who know how to read them, cycle charts can even help identify reproductive health issues, and the menstrual cycle is considered a ‘fifth vital sign’ of overall health in women.
What if fertility awareness users enjoyed the same ease of access, use, and support as HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative participants?
And while, as some have rightly pointed out, a woman working three jobs to make ends meet may not be able to attend a three-and-a-half-hour introductory class or multiple hour-long follow-ups to learn a fertility awareness method, there are organizations working to distill the essential components of mainline, evidence-based fertility awareness methods for use by those least equipped to deal with nasty side effects or health fallout from hormonal-based methods.
The HER Salt Lake City Contraceptive Initiative showed what can happen when women are able to access contraceptive methods in a timely fashion and for free. When will fertility awareness methods enjoy the same level of support?
Live Action News is pro-life news and commentary from a pro-life perspective.
Our work is possible because of our donors. Please consider giving to further our work of changing hearts and minds on issues of life and human dignity.
Contact editor@liveaction.org for questions, corrections, or if you are seeking permission to reprint any Live Action News content.
Guest Articles: To submit a guest article to Live Action News, email editor@liveaction.org with an attached Word document of 800-1000 words. Please also attach any photos relevant to your submission if applicable. If your submission is accepted for publication, you will be notified within three weeks. Guest articles are not compensated (see our Open License Agreement). Thank you for your interest in Live Action News!

Bridget Sielicki
·
Issues
Bernadette Pate
·
Issues
Bridget Sielicki
·
Issues
Sheena Rodriguez
·
Issues
Cassy Cooke
·
International
Cassy Cooke
·
Analysis
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Human Interest
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Issues
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Issues
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·
Issues
Anne Marie Williams, RN, BSN
·