Abortionist only briefly spoke to Keisha Atkins before committing abortion that killed her

abortion, Keisha Atkins

Pro-choice advocates have claimed for years that late-term abortions are only done for health reasons, but a recent video from Abortion On Trial has once again refuted this common myth. The video features Southwestern Women’s Options abortionist Shannon Carr during a 2019 deposition concerning the wrongful death of her patient, Keisha Atkins. During her testimony, Carr struggled to explain why it was medically necessary for Atkins to undergo an abortion at six months gestation. 

Carr claimed in a medical document that Atkins needed the abortion to prevent “substantial and irreversible harm to her physical health, her mental health, her family health, her safety and well being.” But Carr spoke to Atkins for only 20 minutes before making this assessment. 

When the attorneys present at the deposition questioned Carr about the diagnosis, the abortionist admitted the pregnancy posed no “irreversible physical harm” to Atkins’s health. Instead, Carr made assertions about the state of Atkins’s mental health to try and provide a medical justification for a late-term abortion. Carr’s answers, however, were nothing more than mere guesses about Atkins’s frame of mind. 

“That would just be speculation of parenting at a young age as a single mom,” Carr answered when asked how the pregnancy would cause irreversible harm to Atkins’s mental health. “Financially not stable; depression; anxiety. That would be speculation as to any forward effects on her mental health.” 

“I’m not a psychiatrist,” Carr said later, confessing she did not formally assess Atkins’s mental health prior to the abortion. She also admitted she did not use any establish criteria, such as the DSM, to examine Atkins’s mental state. 

Multiple patient charts reveal that Carr and her Southwestern Women’s Options co-workers routinely cite mental health concerns as a reason for a patient’s abortion. Yet none of the employees at the abortion center seem to have the correct qualifications to properly diagnose legitimate mental health conditions. Contrary to her claims about being concerned for the emotional state of pregnant women, Carr revealed she does not conduct any follow-ups to measure her patients’ well-being after late-term abortions. 

READ: Documents reveal Keisha Atkins was repeatedly drugged by abortion facility before her death

Another patient who reportedly had an abortion for mental health reasons is suing the same abortion facility, saying her abortion “left a profound negative impact” on her emotional state. 

Even more egregious in Atkins’s case is the fact that Carr was not her regular doctor, yet the abortion provider made no attempt to examine Atkins’s medical history before carrying out such a procedure on Atkins. 

“If I went to a doctor I had never met before and claimed my arm was causing irreversible harm to my mental and family health and I asked doctors to amputate it, they wouldn’t just oblige my request,” said Abortion on Trial’s Jamie Jeffries said. “Abortion is the only major medical procedure you can access in the middle of a mental breakdown or even a full on psychotic episode and the doctor will just give you what you ask for because you want it.”

“Like” Live Action News on Facebook for more pro-life news and commentary!

What is Live Action News?

Live Action News is pro-life news and commentary from a pro-life perspective. Learn More

Contact for questions, corrections, or if you are seeking permission to reprint any Live Action News content.

GUEST ARTICLES: To submit a guest article to Live Action News, email with an attached Word document of 800-1000 words. Please also attach any photos relevant to your submission if applicable. If your submission is accepted for publication, you will be notified within three weeks. Guest articles are not compensated. (See here for Open License Agreement.) Thank you for your interest in Live Action News!

To Top