For every pro-life argument, a pro-choicer stands ready to mock it without trying to understand it. In response to my Nov. 12 post about why the law takes certain “rights to choose” out of individuals’ hands, our old friend Robin Marty writes that I oppose abortion because I think “women can’t be trusted” and “believe women are incapable of making ‘the right’ decision.”
To be fair, she quotes enough of my post to get my basic point across – but apparently not enough for her to digest it. That’s what makes her response so oddly lacking – she doesn’t try to explain why I’m wrong; she just lets her paraphrases about me distrusting women hang there, as if expecting my knuckle-dragging wrongness to rise self-evident from the page.
This is because abortionism, like all subspecies of liberalism, doesn’t really believe in using reason to discern truth or derive positions; adherents to this ideology decide what they want first, then manipulate whatever emotions they can to help them get it. You don’t trust women is merely one of an arsenal of slogans and buzzwords meant to elicit a Pavlovian response in one’s followers – in this case, they are meant to instinctively recoil in disgust at my alleged disdain for the fairer sex.
Unfortunately for Marty, ten seconds’ worth of non-brainwashed thought about my words – or, in this case, just reading them – would have sufficed to see my real argument: I think “women can’t be trusted” with the power to abort only because I don’t think anyone can be trusted with the power to unilaterally decide whether someone else dies, male or female. Indeed, if the several dozen words I spent explaining my position weren’t enough to convey that to Marty, my use of words like “men,” “people,” “our,” “human,” and “we” should have taken her the rest of the way.
But because genuinely understanding and accurately depicting one’s opponents fall so low on pro-aborts’ priority list, Marty instead settles for the implied sexism cliché, and she makes almost no effort to address the various aspects of my argument – not human nature, not the rights of the unborn (or, indeed, what the unborn even really are), and not the hypocrisy of liberals. The closest she comes to an actual response is this:
Of course, we do have an independent, impartial authority—the courts. At least, we do so far. And that independent, impartial authority ruled that a woman’s right to bodily autonomy supersedes a fertilized egg’s right to be born if the woman doesn’t wish to carry it to term.
Sadly, instead of correcting my fallacies, Marty has introduced a whopper of her own. The true “independent, impartial authority” is the Constitution and the principles it enshrines; the courts settle these questions only to the extent that their rulings faithfully reflect that Constitution and uphold those principles. Roe v. Wade fails that test spectacularly. (And if you don’t believe me, Robin, don’t take Live Action’s word for it – take your own side’s legal experts.)
Robin Marty set out to undermine my argument, but by providing such a great example of the lengths to which abortion apologists will stretch language and reason to keep unborn babies killable, it seems to me she’s only strengthened it.
Stories like the one you just read transform hearts and minds.
For example, one of our followers, Ross, messaged us and commented:
“I began to question my pro-choice views after reading articles about Live Action…Live Action is primarily responsible for my becoming Pro-Life through their well-thought-out, scientific information and the emotionally and uplifting stories of real people with real experiences in saving the lives of their children regardless of what others might say.”
Knowledge is power and CAN open eyes to SEE the truth. And, YOU can provide the spark to transform someone’s mind, just like Ross.
The DAILY publishing at Live Action News is only made possible through generous people, like you, who give $5, $10, or $25.
Your gift today will not only keep these stories coming in 2020, but also help us open more eyes and change minds to be fully pro-life and save lives.
Will you join us in creating a world where the killing of preborn children is unthinkable and support Live Action News by making your tax-deductible gift today?